Flat-or-not

8 Responses

  1. Muhammad El Melegy Muhammad El Melegy

    Lately the argument between going flat or not, Skeuomorphic or not is becoming unbelievable and I'm tired of it so I just want to say it's just called DESIGN.

    Choose whatever suits your project and your style. It's not a must to follow a specific trend or not to follow it.

    That's it. My two cents :)

    and if you want to discuss it further come
    catch me on Twitter

    Edit* The inner shadow in ON ended here by mistake so just ignore it and blame Photoshop for now.

    likes

    about 1 year ago

  2. Falko Joseph Falko Joseph

    The inner shadow in 'ON' doesn't feel like it belongs there, just saying.

    OT: I personally think 'flat UI' is gaining a lot of attention because it's something fresh and new. We've had many design trends based on aqua/shiny effects in the past, which some people grew tired of - just look at all the criticism Apple had with it's somewhat outdated skeuomorphic designs.

    I think Flat UI doesn't feel like any of those "past" trends, nonetheless I do like subtle gradients and shadows here and there. And I'm always in to try something new. :)

    about 1 year ago

  3. Muhammad El Melegy Muhammad El Melegy

    @Falko Joseph Absolutely it doesn't belong there, Damn photoshop didn't notice it's been copied there.

    I agree with you that we've had so many trends in the past. But for me Flat UI is not that new, There are so many designers who has been doing flat UI from long time ago.

    What I want to explain it's in the end called Design so it's not wrong to go flat or wrong to go skeuomorphic. At least for me.

    likes

    about 1 year ago

  4. Mark Bauer Mark Bauer

    To build on that...

    There's something to be said for using skeuomorphism purposefully. The toggles on the right, for example, are leveraging a physical metaphor that people are familiar with, something that can be very beneficial. They don't take up any more space than the flat ones, they're just a different style.

    What bugs me (and I think a lot of other people) is when skeuomorphism is purely ornamental or used arbitrarily. Whatever treatment you decide to give your UI elements, it should be a conscious design decision!

    likes

    about 1 year ago

  5. Brian White Brian White

    I'd venture to change the toggle interior color (subtly) to show on and off on the right shot.

    about 1 year ago

  6. Muhammad El Melegy Muhammad El Melegy

    @Mark Bauer Totally agree with you.

    about 1 year ago

  7. Eli Schiff Eli Schiff

    @Mark Bauer How about the Aesthetic Usability Effect wherein it has been shown that, all else being equal, users find pretty interfaces are easier and more pleasant to use than plain ones?

    Given that this is the case, though this doesn't necessitate using skueomorphic over flat UI, if most users find the most visually pleasing UI to be skeuomorphic, then defaulting to that would make perfect sense, would it not?

    about 1 year ago

  8. Charles Patterson Charles Patterson

    I see 2012 and 2013 here. Move forward :)

    about 1 year ago

keyboard shortcuts: previous shot next shot L or F like