Need some opinions

Arsenal shields

Trying to make a minimal mash-up of a shield, and ranking stripes for a new military themed project. The hope is to show the theme, while also being distinct and showing upward progress (hence the lack of curve in the rank stripes). Not sure if the left most option takes too much out of the design, while the right has too much?

I don't know, hell, that's why I am asking all of you :-)

keyboard shortcuts: L or F like post comment