Simple in-game icon design process

Shop ingame

1 Attachment

Illustrating this for a flash based game. Icon needs to be simple, vector based, and preferably with no gradients or filters at all for better performance. In that case, the challenge is to make the illustration convincing yet simple.
This is my process for this particular icon. However, have not decided on the final result.

Happy Cinco de Mayo!!

keyboard shortcuts: L or F like