Experimenting

Img_5359

12 Responses

  1. Mike Piontek Mike Piontek

    When I originally designed the Delivery Status icon, I think there was a lot more experimentation going on with iPhone icons. Some had 3D effects, some actually made theirs a different shape by giving them a black background. Don't forget the curled corners, either.

    The Delivery Status iPhone icon actually started out as a truck, viewed from an angle—I thought it was fun, but it was admittedly a little weird. For version 2.0 of the app, I realized it made more sense to focus on the thing you're so anxiously awaiting—the package! The top of a box is very flat though, and it didn't make sense to have the glossy effect that many icons use to add depth. A thin bottom edge was a good way to give it some depth without standing out too much.

    These days, we've mostly moved on. I never liked the unusual shapes and I was glad when Apple killed off that idea by adding wallpapers. The more extreme 3D effects seemed like they were pushing it a bit too far. We still have these bottom edges that show up occasionally though. And every time I see a new one I think about how I… don't actually like it. If there was a standard, thin bottom edge we could all agree on that might be something, but maybe we're just better off without it.

    So I've decided to try experimenting with something simpler. The best iOS icons are often the simplest ones. You don't want your icon to be too flat, but emphasizing gradients or subtle highlights and shadows can go a long way. These will take some getting used to for me, but I think I actually like them more. Thoughts?

    likes

    about 1 year ago

  2. Josh Greco Josh Greco

    For what it's worth, I can tell that you've put a lot of thought and consideration into this and it looks fantastic. The edge is subtle but it adds a certain 'press-ability' that I really enjoy. Stay the course Mr. Piontek!

    about 1 year ago

  3. Jake Desaulniers Jake Desaulniers

    While I've always thought your icons were very tastefully executed I am fully behind the move not having any faux-3D. As a guy who prefers dark wallpapers, I've always found the 3D effect made icons appear even more uneven. I look forward to seeing these bad boys on my homescreen.

    likes

    about 1 year ago

  4. Kevin Clark Kevin Clark

    @Mike Piontek : Thanks for the great insight into your thinking behind this version. The new icon looks great, ship it.

    about 1 year ago

  5. Ketan Ketan

    Bravo!

    about 1 year ago

  6. Nick Looijmans Nick Looijmans

    Great move. I hope a lot of apps follow in your footsteps.

    Looking at you, Google!

    about 1 year ago

  7. Janik Baumgartner Janik Baumgartner

    Yes, please!

    about 1 year ago

  8. Raven Yu Raven Yu

    @Mike Piontek Exactly. The worst part is that unlike OS X (which has guidelines for icon perspective), everyone of these iOS icons has a different perspective. Together they are just a mess. Actually I think Apple should advise against it. And I agree the simple ones are the best. :)

    about 1 year ago

  9. Tim Van Damme Tim Van Damme

    Madly in love with this redesign for all the reasons people mentioned here already.

    likes

    about 1 year ago

  10. Daniel Waldron Daniel Waldron

    Definitely all for removeing the 3D I always loved these icons, but the 3D effect, although tolerable, bugged me a bit. These versions here are tits.

    about 1 year ago

  11. Sebastiaan de With Sebastiaan de With

    all my yes, this is my main quibble with the icons.

    about 1 year ago

  12. Piotr Denis Piotr Denis

    If you are thinking of simplicity take a look at what Apple did to Reminders icon from early beta to final one and take a look at "address" texts. Maybe black/gray rectangles could simplify even more and still keep the meaning :) Anyway, good job !

    about 1 year ago

keyboard shortcuts: previous shot next shot L or F like