Top or Bottom?

18 Responses

1. Ryan Hamrick

   Well?

   7 months ago

2. Neil Tasker

   bottom for me!

   7 months ago

3. Alen Type08 Pavlovic

   Bottom reads more as 9D, so it depends on what this is for...

   1likes

   7 months ago

4. Curt Street

   Top. Kinda looks like a DNA double helix.

   7 months ago

5. Elliot Jackson

   Depends on the look you're going for.
   Top feels more modern, bottom feels more classical.
   If it's for a logo the overall thicker lines on the top one would probably make it look better at different sizes when printed.
   Both look good :)

   7 months ago

6. Melissa Frost

   Love them both. Same feedback as everyone else - depends on what you're using it for... which isn't very helpful at this point I guess ;) Personally I'm leaning toward the top.

   7 months ago

7. Ryan Davis

   There's more letterplay happening in the top one, so there's a little more visual interest there, in my opinion. Both are solid.

   7 months ago

8. Jesus

   Bottom

   7 months ago

9. Jacob Koesterich

   I agree with @Elliot top is something different/modern, bottom feels more classic.

   7 months ago

10. Gerren Lamson

    Seems like a visual concept is trying to come through the type on the top option, where as the bottom is purely a styled typographic solution. Great sketches, Ryan.

    7 months ago

11. Brendan Pittman

    If this is for a logo, I like the top.

    7 months ago

12. William Dalebout

    I just got you to 2000.

    7 months ago

13. Sam Jones

    I thought exactly the same as @Curt about the top one when I first saw it. As others have said though, it really depends on what these are for. Personally I like them both.

    6 months ago

14. Arno Kathollnig

    BOTTOM!!!

    6 months ago

15. Travis Stevens

    Yeah I love that bottom logo.. That's slick as hell!

    6 months ago

16. Andrew Hicks

    I like the way the bottom looks best, but I think the top is a little more readable. Both look awesome though!

    6 months ago

17. Eric Atha

    Top.

    6 months ago

18. IXD Final Sketch Shooting this one off now for final approval before jumping into Illustrator. Biggun attached.

    Rebound

    IXD Final Sketch

    by Ryan Hamrick

    Shooting this one off now for final approval before jumping into Illustrator.

    Biggun attached.

    • 32
    • 5
    • 315

    6 months ago