Maybe this is my Northern Craziness but I wish the main logo was a little more different than the rest. I know the star is highlighted for a state, but I sat here trying to figure out what state was "SDU" for way too long. Overall I love the style, just minor thought from my perspective.
These are great. All the elements work really nicely together. Not sure about the stars though—why is highlighting the alphabetical order of the states particularly important? I don't know if this is possible or even makes sense, but the stars might be more meaningful if they represented the geographic locations of the states relative to each other. So Florida would get the bottom right star highlighted, Arkansas the top left, etc. I dunno, just a thought.
I second both @Kristin Lasita & @Stewart Scott-Curran. I would also like to add that the use of pencil + mouse, just seems outdated to me now in the idea of design tools..... maybe that's just me & everyone works with different things, but I feel like a Wacom stylus is more the tool than a mouse... Just my take! But it looks great!
@Jillian Adel Totally get what you mean but my idea for this included more than just working on the computer... that's why i wanted an analog tool as well as a digital tool. I still never got into the wacom thing anyways... haha
I'll explain the project more as i develop it a bit more.
Still playing with options for how the name sits with it as well.
I love the ambition here. Maybe you could have a playoff on Dribbble to come up w/ an icon for each state to replace the stars. So if I'm from Texas, I might design an icon for TX, and try to get other texans to like it. That way people from each state really take ownership over their chapter of the union.
Ooooo, great idea @Philip Clark ! I wish I was from any of those states so I could participate...but I'm basically an honorary Texan :P
@Jeremy Pettis I don't think that I'd agree with you that mouses/mice are timeless/iconic of being a designer at all. No technology in design is really timeless...besides the pencil, I'd argue. But that's a discussion for another forum & day maybe.
@Chris Rushing Definitely looking forward to hearing more backstory & seeing what these are going to be used for!
wow these are great :) i like the saturated versions. And I like the idea of incorporating the pencil because that's a timeless tool. It seems like everyone has contrasting opinions, though - so do what you want! you're definitely doing it right!
15 Responses
Pro
Chris Rushing
Side project continued... Working on colors.
All opinions are welcome.
Larger in the attachment.
A more saturated set can be seen here: http://bit.ly/Nr72Fr
I'm from Georgia by the way... just in case someone asks.
10 months ago
Yee-haw.
10 months ago
Pro
Cameron Roberson
Looking great. I approve of this Southern Design Union!
10 months ago
Maybe this is my Northern Craziness but I wish the main logo was a little more different than the rest. I know the star is highlighted for a state, but I sat here trying to figure out what state was "SDU" for way too long. Overall I love the style, just minor thought from my perspective.
9 months ago
Pro
Stewart Scott-Curran
Like the unsaturated versions....
9 months ago
These are great. All the elements work really nicely together. Not sure about the stars though—why is highlighting the alphabetical order of the states particularly important? I don't know if this is possible or even makes sense, but the stars might be more meaningful if they represented the geographic locations of the states relative to each other. So Florida would get the bottom right star highlighted, Arkansas the top left, etc. I dunno, just a thought.
9 months ago
Pro
Jillian Adel
I second both @Kristin Lasita & @Stewart Scott-Curran. I would also like to add that the use of pencil + mouse, just seems outdated to me now in the idea of design tools..... maybe that's just me & everyone works with different things, but I feel like a Wacom stylus is more the tool than a mouse... Just my take! But it looks great!
9 months ago
Pro
Chris Rushing
@Jillian Adel Totally get what you mean but my idea for this included more than just working on the computer... that's why i wanted an analog tool as well as a digital tool. I still never got into the wacom thing anyways... haha
I'll explain the project more as i develop it a bit more.
Still playing with options for how the name sits with it as well.
Thanks all!
9 months ago
prefer the pencil + mouse. wacom stylus is not as timeless / iconic
9 months ago
Pro
Philip Clark
I love the ambition here. Maybe you could have a playoff on Dribbble to come up w/ an icon for each state to replace the stars. So if I'm from Texas, I might design an icon for TX, and try to get other texans to like it. That way people from each state really take ownership over their chapter of the union.
9 months ago
Pro
Jillian Adel
Ooooo, great idea @Philip Clark ! I wish I was from any of those states so I could participate...but I'm basically an honorary Texan :P
@Jeremy Pettis I don't think that I'd agree with you that mouses/mice are timeless/iconic of being a designer at all. No technology in design is really timeless...besides the pencil, I'd argue. But that's a discussion for another forum & day maybe.
@Chris Rushing Definitely looking forward to hearing more backstory & seeing what these are going to be used for!
9 months ago
wow these are great :) i like the saturated versions. And I like the idea of incorporating the pencil because that's a timeless tool. It seems like everyone has contrasting opinions, though - so do what you want! you're definitely doing it right!
9 months ago
@Jillian Adel http://i.istockimg.com/file_thumbview_approve/1240652/2/stock-photo-1240652-scientist-shrug-on-white.jpg
9 months ago
Pro
Jillian Adel
@Jeremy Pettis this is where we become friends on all of the internets.
9 months ago
Pro
Chris Rushing
@Jeremy Pettis @Jillian Adel nowkiss.jpg
9 months ago