How do people know they are signing up via Facebook, there is also no way to register, or remember login details, or select between Spotify & Facebook if they have legacy account.
But yeah, visually the added padding makes it look better.
It looks a lot cleaner but misses a lot of functionality. Like @Peter Tait already said. I also agree with because you don't have to sign in with Facebook, it is just a possibility.
It kills me that only two people pointed out that you've compromised functionality for an admittedly "better looking" interface.
As @Peter Tait and @Hidde van der Ploeg have already pointed out, it's very unclear that a user would have to use their facebook credentials in order to sign in. Additionally, the ability to have it remember your credentials once you've entered them is missing along with the ability to sign up for a new account.
I don't have a strong opinion on taking it upon yourself to re-design something that's been bothering you, I've done it myself, but at least try to think about how you'd improve both the visuals as well as the functionality.
28 Responses (page 1 of 2)
Pro
Thom
I'm fiddling around a bit with Photoshop CS6. I'm liking it so far. :)
Here's Spotify's current login window. I don't really like it. Which is why I've redesigned it. :3
tweet this
10 months ago
Much better than the original, as always. ;)
10 months ago
This is awesome...
10 months ago
Pro
Elliot
I already said it rocks ;)
10 months ago
Pro
Dan Lebowitz
I like the spacing in the shot much more than the attachment, but really nice improvement from the current design.
10 months ago
Pro
Jamie Brittain
Nice man! I love Spotify, I just hate login with Facebook and all the Facebook popup thingys.
10 months ago
Nice, but the colors are a bit dull though
10 months ago
It looks good, but I'm not so sure about that blue button, since it reminds me a lot of Facebook. Try green.
10 months ago
Pro
Bobby Giangeruso
I don't know if I like it. Maybe you could make it a bit worse, so it's not so fucking awesome!?
10 months ago
Pro
Aqib Mushtaq
Great as always Thom!
10 months ago
Pro
Manu Gamero ☁
Nice! Did you consider the idea of making a green button?
10 months ago
Pro
Thom
@Manu for sure! I used blue since people need to sign in with facebook. ;)
10 months ago
How do people know they are signing up via Facebook, there is also no way to register, or remember login details, or select between Spotify & Facebook if they have legacy account.
But yeah, visually the added padding makes it look better.
10 months ago
Pro
Dhiren Adesara
looks nice @Thom
10 months ago
Pro
Hidde van der Ploeg
It looks a lot cleaner but misses a lot of functionality. Like @Peter Tait already said. I also agree with because you don't have to sign in with Facebook, it is just a possibility.
10 months ago
Pro
Alphabit
well done @Thom
10 months ago
Pro
Victor Erixon
Great job mate!
10 months ago
Pro
Chris Welch
It kills me that only two people pointed out that you've compromised functionality for an admittedly "better looking" interface.
As @Peter Tait and @Hidde van der Ploeg have already pointed out, it's very unclear that a user would have to use their facebook credentials in order to sign in. Additionally, the ability to have it remember your credentials once you've entered them is missing along with the ability to sign up for a new account.
I don't have a strong opinion on taking it upon yourself to re-design something that's been bothering you, I've done it myself, but at least try to think about how you'd improve both the visuals as well as the functionality.
10 months ago
Pro
Nils Helmersson
Another thing if you‘re only re-designing a specific part, check out the design guidelines (if you haven’t).
10 months ago
Very good work.
10 months ago
Pro
Mathieu Berenguer ▲▼▲
Nice work dude. :)
10 months ago
Rebound
Spotify login rebound
by Pete Avey
Reeebound
10 months ago
Pro
Lewis Braid
This is really nice! Very clean.
10 months ago
Rebound
Rdio Sign In (Freebie)
by Dan Edwards
Love Thom's work so figured I'd give a login window a go.
Full pixels
Download the PSD
9 months ago
Rebound
Spotify Login Window
by David Jakowenko
My take on the Spotify login box.
9 months ago