both are nice, but imho both feature a tiny problem... although the main cog is clearly visible in both, the other two are left too isolated and cropped too tightly, leaving them as un-defined bits "sortof" connected to the big cog wheel. Have you tried perhaps reducing the radius of the main wheel by 5 px and lifting the other two slightly? (I think they become far better visible once a bit more of their center hole is within the crop-area)
That being said, I like the one on the right for its simplicity and although somewhat muted shadows... the contrast and shading is striking :)
9 Responses
Hey guys,
Which Icon is better?
11 months ago
My voice for the left one)
11 months ago
both are nice, but imho both feature a tiny problem... although the main cog is clearly visible in both, the other two are left too isolated and cropped too tightly, leaving them as un-defined bits "sortof" connected to the big cog wheel. Have you tried perhaps reducing the radius of the main wheel by 5 px and lifting the other two slightly? (I think they become far better visible once a bit more of their center hole is within the crop-area)
That being said, I like the one on the right for its simplicity and although somewhat muted shadows... the contrast and shading is striking :)
11 months ago
@Contrastblack® thanks for strong feedback!
11 months ago
Rebound
Kog Wheel rebound
by Contrastblack®
Here's what I was referring to :P Was just targetting the proportions, the quality overall is nowhere near yours :)
11 months ago
Left one :)
11 months ago
And the winner is .... lllleeeefftt!!!
11 months ago
Yeah! Sexy thing:) Left jag need double check.
11 months ago
2
11 months ago