Reason I prefer the light? Better contrast between it and the darker top of the page container behind it. That, and when you hover over an item on the white background, not only does the link's background color change to blue, the actual text changes color too. All pluses IMO.
I'm torn, these both look great. I like the look of the dark a little better but wonder if it's as readable with lots of results (would have to see on a bigger screen). Great use of an animated gif btw!
Love the dark as a designer, but light seems more user friendly and accepted by a general audience. I go through these same debates nearly every time I design.
19 Responses
Working on a search dropdown with grouped results. Can't decide on a dark or light background. Both have their pros/cons. Hm...
over 2 years ago
I think the black background is way nicer.
over 2 years ago
Hmm it's hard to decide between the 2 with only a dribbble size preview.
As it looks like the content is on a white background, the search results should probably be darker in order to stand out and draw attention.
over 2 years ago
Put me down for another vote for the darker style.
over 2 years ago
I dig the dark, but I prefer the light version. Either way, both look nice.
over 2 years ago
Yeah but did I click the like button when the image was dark or light?
over 2 years ago
I love dark!
over 2 years ago
You're all making this much more difficult. I was leaning towards white for scannability/readability. *bangs head against table*
over 2 years ago
Reason I prefer the light? Better contrast between it and the darker top of the page container behind it. That, and when you hover over an item on the white background, not only does the link's background color change to blue, the actual text changes color too. All pluses IMO.
over 2 years ago
I prefer the darker. PS - As an Rdio subscriber, I'd love to see this!
over 2 years ago
I like the darker version but possibly make it transparent a bit more may add a nice effect.
over 2 years ago
I like the white one. Seems more "modal"
over 2 years ago
Rebound
Rdio Search Concept
by Jason Long
A quick rebound with another take on Adam's cool search concepts.
over 2 years ago
I'm torn, these both look great. I like the look of the dark a little better but wonder if it's as readable with lots of results (would have to see on a bigger screen). Great use of an animated gif btw!
over 2 years ago
Light.
over 2 years ago
dark of course!
over 2 years ago
Love the dark as a designer, but light seems more user friendly and accepted by a general audience. I go through these same debates nearly every time I design.
almost 2 years ago
Nice work man!
over 1 year ago
black is better :)
over 1 year ago