Elizabeth & Co. - Round 2

Elizabeth-sm2

11 Responses

  1. Joseph Alessio Joseph Alessio

    And here goes round 2! Changed the typeface to a humanist sans per suggestions from @Jeff and @Claire, fixed the stroke per @Neil's suggestion, and per @Jillian's great feedback I tracked out the type, simplified the ornamentation, and added weight to the serif characters, etc. How does this work?

    likes

    12 months ago

  2. Whitney CPBG Whitney CPBG

    I feel like this one is lightyears from the other, just from the simple changes - and I loved the first version too! Great job.

    likes

    12 months ago

  3. Patrick Rogan Patrick Rogan

    I'd second that, you did a great job, Joe~

    likes

    12 months ago

  4. Jillian Adel Jillian Adel

    Definitely much better. I think the two things that are still kinda irking me are having "Co." twice. Just seems repetitive...and that big ol' E in the circle just feels like its cramped.... Crazy idea, but maybe blow that circle up bigger so the bottom most point overlaps the other background shape a little? Might bring the two shapes together too...

    likes

    12 months ago

  5. Ben Suarez Ben Suarez

    This typeface is working a lot better I think. What I did like about the last one was the differentiating stroke widths on the motif.

    Looks great!

    likes

    12 months ago

  6. Jeff Jenkins Jeff Jenkins

    Great improvement, Joseph! The weight balance between serif and non-serif is much better. What would take this to the next level is to adjust the letterforms to better follow the curve of the banner. There's good information on this in Leslie Cabarga's book Logo, Font & Lettering Bible. Well worth the investment if you don't already have it.

    likes

    12 months ago

  7. Joseph Alessio Joseph Alessio

    Thanks @Whitney! Tiny changes can really make a big difference, can't they! It's the difference between polished and amateur.

    Thanks @Patrick!

    Good to hear some of the issues were solved @Jillian! I tried to hold on to that "Co" in the monogram but if you really think it's a bad idea I should take your word for it! ;D Then the "E" would have more room, also. Good idea on overlapping the shapes, I'd intended to do that earlier but somehow forgot it in the process.

    Yeah I agree @Ben, it's a little more open and not quite so heavy. I feel you on the more uneven strokes, I'll have to find the balance between the two.

    Thanks @Jeff! That book sounds like a veritable treasure chest, I'll have to look it up - thanks for mentioning it! Are you thinking of actually tweaking the characters, or improving on Illustrator's imperfectly curved baseline?

    12 months ago

  8. Jeff Jenkins Jeff Jenkins

    Tweaking the characters. Here's an example of what I mean:

    http://is.gd/mu3sR7

    12 months ago

  9. Andy Anzollitto Andy Anzollitto

    All good improvements! There is one thing I would consider adjusting. The ornaments seem to get lost when paired with the outer stroke on the circle and rectangle. Perhaps add a thicker stroke on just the perimeter of the ornamentation to tie it all in?

    12 months ago

  10. Claire Coullon Claire Coullon

    Just catching this now, fantastic improvements! That typeface works beautifully now, much more cohesive overall. I hate being late to comments.. always tricky to spot something that hasn't already been mentioned, haha. The ornamentation looks really nice too (you could almost get away with removing the inner-most thin white outline in the circle.. that said though, I do like that its weight helps to mirror the strokes of the flourishes).

    likes

    12 months ago

  11. Joseph Alessio Joseph Alessio

    Thanks @Claire! You're right, I should probably remove that stroke. Removing things is always the hard part but it's also very important!

    likes

    12 months ago

keyboard shortcuts: previous shot next shot L or F like