@Lauri Johnston Thanks! Alternates are a slippery slope. Include too many, and the typeface will never get finished! Also, I find people so rarely use them.
@Neil Tasker They're comin alon. The 3 that you like matches the 5 and 7 well.
i think right, right, right, left. But both Bs look solid.
IMHO the right hand 3 feels a little house number to me. left hand 3 feels like it fits with what I have seen thus far. Might be different in context with other digits.
It'd be nice to see a rebound with these in context. Isolated glyph battles might be fun—and pretty—but fun and pretty glyphs don't necessarily add up to a harmonized typeface.
Anyway, I say the second B in Round 3 could take the other seven in a street brawl. (Now I kinda want a 'face named Brawl.) Keep up the fight, James!
28 Responses (page 1 of 2)
Many of these decisions have been made, but this shows the glyph battles that go on in my head while designing type.
12 months ago
Winners so far:
Round 1: right (the left part of the first one was colliding with other characters).
Round 2: right (the left was too fancy compared to the other caps).
Round 3: right (just too pippin not to go with). Also, the same format works well on the cap D.
Round 4: UNDECIDED.
12 months ago
f: right
C: left
B: left
3: left
they're all awesome. are you doing a typeface? definitely include alternates!
12 months ago
Pro
Neil Tasker
how are the other numbers looking? I really like the right with the horizontal brush stroke, but might not match the others
12 months ago
@Lauri Johnston Thanks! Alternates are a slippery slope. Include too many, and the typeface will never get finished! Also, I find people so rarely use them.
@Neil Tasker They're comin alon. The 3 that you like matches the 5 and 7 well.
12 months ago
round 1: right
round 2: right
round 3: left
round 4: right
12 months ago
Pro
Neil Tasker
@James T. Edmondson Yeah I was gonna say it would fit well on a 5 and 7 great, thats my pick, sweet work as always, excited to see it all
12 months ago
Pro
Anthony Lane
Right, Right, Left, Left. Out of this set those are what feels most consistent to me. Nice work hun.
12 months ago
1. Right
2. Right
3. Left
4. Right
12 months ago
Pro
Nayla Smith
I like all rights! These are wonderful.
12 months ago
My feedback would be: Keep it simple. :)
12 months ago
@Henry Moran always sound advice Henry!
12 months ago
I like whichever ones you like James. In my heart it just feels so right.
12 months ago
Pro
Chris Rushing
Right
Left
Left
Right
In all honesty you should just have a ton of alternate glyphs.
12 months ago
Wait a minute! With opentype you don't have to choose anymore! ;)
11 months ago
Pro
dan gneiding
i think right, right, right, left. But both Bs look solid.
IMHO the right hand 3 feels a little house number to me. left hand 3 feels like it fits with what I have seen thus far. Might be different in context with other digits.
Keep up the great work Step Dad.
11 months ago
@Tiffany Wardle de Sousa I wish you could just draw both and the OpenType, kerning, and necessary ligatures would just figure themselves out :)
@dan gneiding the right 3 is working surprisingly well. I am torn. Need to look at more signs. Call me "dad".
11 months ago
Pro
Luke Ritchie
Sho! Looking forward to this guys release. You should have a limited release to avoid overuse, haha
11 months ago
@Luke Ritchie The fonts will be released on floppy disk only.
11 months ago
Pro
Luke Ritchie
@James T. Edmondson hah! Could i get a faxed copy?
11 months ago
Pro
Dominik Levytskyi
1:right
2:right
3:left definitely
4:left probably fits the style at most
11 months ago
Pro
Mads Burcharth
The right f touched my tralala.
11 months ago
Pro
André Mora
It'd be nice to see a rebound with these in context. Isolated glyph battles might be fun—and pretty—but fun and pretty glyphs don't necessarily add up to a harmonized typeface.
Anyway, I say the second B in Round 3 could take the other seven in a street brawl. (Now I kinda want a 'face named Brawl.) Keep up the fight, James!
11 months ago
@André Mora Couldn't agree more. More people are chiming in around here than expected! I'm totally with you on the B. Thanks André!
11 months ago
Pro
Jordi Verdu
Left F, Right C, Left B, Left 3.
Hadoouken!
11 months ago