Interesting idea. I make sure I check/view everything with the red badge, if not I feel like they're yelling at me. They make me feel ashamed, like i'm lazy...maybe I am, huh.
Do you think it would be too simplistic to eliminate the badges completely, and replace then with a different app icon state? We'd lose the exactness of knowing that we have 21 new articles to read, but it could read less like a demand and more like a suggestion.
Justin, I think it would be fantastic—or give devs the added option of some kind of “unfinished” status in addition to the numeric badge. I didn't explore any of those design options, but I think it would be fun to. I'd rather know I have unread RSS items than the specific number of items.
8 Responses
Pro
Grant Blakeman
I would love to see this happen. Red is so, so, unnecessary.
over 1 year ago
Pro
TJ Taylor
Interesting idea. I make sure I check/view everything with the red badge, if not I feel like they're yelling at me. They make me feel ashamed, like i'm lazy...maybe I am, huh.
Anyway, the blue is nice.
over 1 year ago
Pro
Grant Blakeman
Yeah, TJ, that's exactly the point. It's silly to feel that way about email, let alone RSS feeds or games in Words-with-Friends—yet many of us do.
I'm not even entirely sold on the blue as the solution, but not making it red would be huge.
over 1 year ago
Pro
Russell Bishop
Interesting: I just noticed that in my iTunes, if there's a new TV show episode, I get the blue alert circle.
over 1 year ago
Pro
Grant Blakeman
Russell, very interesting. I hadn't noticed that.
over 1 year ago
I completely agree with your views, I don't even show my reeder unread count because it is just such an eyesore having 550 in red LOL
over 1 year ago
Pro
Justin Lascelle
Do you think it would be too simplistic to eliminate the badges completely, and replace then with a different app icon state? We'd lose the exactness of knowing that we have 21 new articles to read, but it could read less like a demand and more like a suggestion.
over 1 year ago
Pro
Grant Blakeman
Justin, I think it would be fantastic—or give devs the added option of some kind of “unfinished” status in addition to the numeric badge. I didn't explore any of those design options, but I think it would be fun to. I'd rather know I have unread RSS items than the specific number of items.
over 1 year ago