I'm definitely a fan of the first registration timeline you were using. I believe the way you show progress in this timeline is more clear and effective, but the sexyness of the first timeline is killer. If you had the progress highlighted on the path on the first timeline or some other way of displaying percent complete, I'd say stick with that one. It's less expected than this timeline.
definitely minimal, it went so good with all that BG! The only thing I felt was it required a little more affordance on where user are like an tiny arrow depiction may be!
I was going to say minimal but I also like this version as well though. The only issue visually you might run into is the background being clear and might blur into it a little... minimal is always nice! Good work Bill!
16 Responses
Pro
Bill S Kenney
Working on a revised version of the registration timeline I was using. Do you prefer this over the more minimal previous shot?
about 1 year ago
Pro
John Ashenden
Previous shot wins.
about 1 year ago
prefer the former, but not to know which is better without seeing the context
about 1 year ago
Pro
Bill S Kenney
thanks guys @John and undertand @Andrey
about 1 year ago
Pro
Sahand Nayebaziz
I'm definitely a fan of the first registration timeline you were using. I believe the way you show progress in this timeline is more clear and effective, but the sexyness of the first timeline is killer. If you had the progress highlighted on the path on the first timeline or some other way of displaying percent complete, I'd say stick with that one. It's less expected than this timeline.
It's skinny and sexy and killer
about 1 year ago
Pro
David Elgena
I prefer the previous!
about 1 year ago
Pro
Brian Lovin
Yeah, I'd like to see the full thing, but I liked the first one more.
about 1 year ago
previous shot, absolutely. minimal is better.
about 1 year ago
Pro
Bill S Kenney
Like where this is going =) @Nick @Brian @David @Sahand @Andrey
Back to minimal - glad I checked
about 1 year ago
Pro
Enrique Sánchez
I like both a lot! Would have to view the whole thing to see which one works better with the rest of the design...
about 1 year ago
Pro
Jeremy Buff
My preference would be the previous design. I'm a sucker for a clean/minimal look.
about 1 year ago
Pro
Avinash Tripathi
definitely minimal, it went so good with all that BG! The only thing I felt was it required a little more affordance on where user are like an tiny arrow depiction may be!
about 1 year ago
Pro
Dreamway Studios (via Mich...
prefer the minimal previous shot more, the fade doesn't look that attractive as the minimal one.
about 1 year ago
Pro
Bill S Kenney
Thanks again for all the feedback. Minimal it is then.
about 1 year ago
I was going to say minimal but I also like this version as well though. The only issue visually you might run into is the background being clear and might blur into it a little... minimal is always nice! Good work Bill!
about 1 year ago
Pro
Michele Macklin
The minimal is best for sure! It is more refined and striking.
about 1 year ago