I'm liking the one on the right. Only thing that I'd adjust is the difference between the staple and the string holes glossiness. My guess is that both should have the same reflection.
This base is really great. I like better the right because of the handbag feeling.
I don't really dig the dollar characters, maybe too big or because of the font.
Seriously? I was just making an icon thinking "wow its gonna be the best one ever"... Yeah thanks for ruining my hopes and dreams!!!! Oh and nice work on the icon. Its perfect.
@Jan Vu Nam Good suggestion! I can move the handle up but I've a feeling that it will make the bottom part empty and top part too cramped.Does that make sense?
Sweet stuff as usual! The one on the right is a winner for me. I do think the stitches look a little too much like they're just pixel rectangles/bars instead of stiches, perhaps fool around with some subtle bevel to make them seem more like they're 3d?
49 Responses (page 1 of 2)
Working on this icon right now.Suggestions and criticism will be appreciated.
Personally, I prefer the right one.Who's with me?
about 1 year ago
Pro
Andrea Cau
Criticism? U MAD BRO? :)
about 1 year ago
Pro
Jan Vu Nam
I love the right one. Have you been thinking about putting the handle little bit higher to make it more like bag? .)
about 1 year ago
Pro
Bobby Giangeruso
Uhm, one thing you forgot was to do a bad job on the design. Other then that I believe this is AMAZING ;D
about 1 year ago
Pro
Paul Ungureanu
I'm liking the one on the right. Only thing that I'd adjust is the difference between the staple and the string holes glossiness. My guess is that both should have the same reflection.
about 1 year ago
Pro
Guillaume Gaubert
This base is really great. I like better the right because of the handbag feeling.
I don't really dig the dollar characters, maybe too big or because of the font.
about 1 year ago
What @AndyTheJoker said!
about 1 year ago
Pro
Mitchell Bernstein
Seriously? I was just making an icon thinking "wow its gonna be the best one ever"... Yeah thanks for ruining my hopes and dreams!!!! Oh and nice work on the icon. Its perfect.
about 1 year ago
Pro
Lukas Bugla
Nice.
about 1 year ago
It looks, amazing ! Would love to come with some critics, but can find anything wrong here !
about 1 year ago
Pro
Brian Lovin
The right one for sure, very beautiful.
about 1 year ago
Pro
Ollin
One on the left is more unique, right one looks stylish. I would suggest making the shadows darker/less red though.
about 1 year ago
Love it!
about 1 year ago
Pro
Anna Paschenko
I like the left one :-P
As for me single $ will be better. Or it's a logo?
about 1 year ago
I have a suggestion stop making us look bad! just kidding, the right one is sweet, textures are so so good and subtle too!
about 1 year ago
I'm with you! I really like the right one!
about 1 year ago
Pro
zee7 ✽
looky good, a few things i'd like to point out.
Right one:
The metallic holes don't look good with the angled white shades on top. have you thought about making them smooth?
The shadow beneath to the rope can be better by making it darker from right/left corners and lighter/blurred from centre.
The latch ... hmmm.. the edges are too dark, i would add a highlighted stroke to make it stand out and its shadow can also be improved.
Baki fit hai love the metallic button and shades on it
about 1 year ago
Does the latch look too flat? Could it look more 3d at the top so its as though the latch is slightly biting into below?? If that makes sense
about 1 year ago
@Asher How do you make such beautiful textures? Right one is better in my opinion. Left is not so perfectly simple :D
about 1 year ago
@Jan Vu Nam Good suggestion! I can move the handle up but I've a feeling that it will make the bottom part empty and top part too cramped.Does that make sense?
@Paul Ungureanu Good point indeed.
@Mitchell Bernstein Sorry but I assure you it was not intentional ;)
@Anna Paschenko It's their logo.I was also intending to use single $.
@zee7 ✽ Thanks for the suggestions.I'll post an update soon.
@Damian Kidd The latch was a lazy addition.I'll make it look better once the client approves the concept.
Thanks everyone for the positive response :)
about 1 year ago
Man I'm super jealous of your skill set. This is awesome!
about 1 year ago
I prefer the right,
it would be a wallet, with a mixed bag?
I agree with the suggestions of @zee7 ✽, and add a slight texture on the cord
about 1 year ago
Pro
Yummygum
Sweet stuff as usual! The one on the right is a winner for me. I do think the stitches look a little too much like they're just pixel rectangles/bars instead of stiches, perhaps fool around with some subtle bevel to make them seem more like they're 3d?
about 1 year ago
Lovely.
about 1 year ago
Pro
Fabio Benedetti
@Asher lovely details on the right hand side one. Great work ++
about 1 year ago