Once again, I need help selecting the one that's more suitable.Personally, I think the left one looks simple and different.It can be integrated to smaller versions nicely as well.
Suggestions and criticism will be appreciated :)
about 1 year ago
Left is the better icon. :)
I like the right one ; )
I like the left one, but I can't figure out what that page curl is doing there. Love the details, though!
The one on the right is more recognisable at a glance imo.
i think the one on the left would better apply to a brand or app name (if this is for an app).. i.e a logo could slot in nicely onto the record sleeve.
the other one is really nice, but kind of just a generic record player.
Depends on the function - right side feels turntable-ish like it's a player while the left side feels more collector-ish, like it's a store. Either way, they're awesome.
I agree with @Bob Case
Definitely left just remove the curl :)
And what @Bob Case said
This part is out of perspective http://cl.ly/F1y4
However I vote for the first one.
What about ?, getting feedback from those in here and some mine.
Semantically speaking, the one on the left has elements that aren't congruent. A sleeve over a wooden backdrop with a page curl? I'm not seeing any connection.
I opt for the right. It may not have the same flare (personally, I prefer it even just artistically), but semantically, everything works.
I'm a fan of the right :)
If you centered the plate on the turntable I would go for right.
they're awesome, great work as always!
Glad I referred Meshal to you!
Depends on the main function you want to make it more prominent.
The left looks more like a songs/albums management, the right is more like its players.
I'm about to pick up the right ones, it nice, but sadly its too mainstream :p , just like a generic music player apps.
So I prefer the left ones.
With some quote from @Pete White : i.e a logo could slot in nicely onto the record sleeve.
@Jackie Tran Check this image.
@Juan Gomez Thanks! I am definitely going to use that effect if the client goes with the left one.
@William Szilveszter In the left icon, I imagine the vinyl to come out from the sleeve with table in background.The curl has its importance considering the function of the app.
@童真鸣 Actually, @Kubilay Sapayer used my icon as an inspiration :)
@Sean Farrell You are the man :)
@Aditya Nugraha Putra Expect a rebound soon :)
Thanks everyone for the suggestions.
Oh i see, I though that's a cartridge.
In that case, that long part of the head-shell should be in black, because the head-shell is black plastic. ;)
Left one would be my first choise too ;)
Dude i love this style! My vote is for the left one.
keyboard shortcuts: ← previous shot → next shot L or F like
Show and tell for designers
What are you working on? Dribbble is a community of designers sharing screenshots of their work, process, and projects.
Copyright © 2009–2013 Dribbble LLC. All screenshots © their respective owners. Shipped from Salem, Mass. USA.
Follow Dribbble on Twitter