Icon of an app designed for Pinterest.I really can't decide which version looks more appropriate.My client believes that the icon doesn't relate to the site except the 'P'.So, both can be rejected as well.If you have a better idea/metaphor, do tell.
Nice Asher! I think I dig the second one the best. I think whats throwing it off is the "P". I think this feels more like a note taking app because the "P" is so much different than the Pinterest "P" - which I think would look really good in this icon. Just a thought :D
Both of them are really good man @Asher I would go for the second one, but I feel like there shoud be just one paper pinned (like in the forst one) or at least a darker shadow between the sheets. It should be white because the yellow one reminds me about the sticky notes which you never actually pin.
Besides that, I totally agree with @Mike Cummings a handwritten "P" is going to look so much better. Why don't you use the "P" from the actual Pinterest logo?
I really like that kind of posts on dribbble, that's what dribbble is all about, getting feedback from a truly creative and experienced community and not just showing off!
I am definitely going to use white note(s) on left frame.The reason why I avoided Pinterest logo was copyright infringement which, I believe, is not going to be a problem.
I'll work on ithe icon and will post the update soon.Thanks everyone for the constructive criticism :)
@Mike Cummings and @Ilie Ciorba not difficult to agree with them ;) handwritten "P" from logo will do the trick :) and like i write on twitter - right one are much better for me ;)
The pin is spot on! My vote definitely goes for the updated version except I would change the shadow/stroke of the paper cause it looks a tad too sharp and orange. Grooves on the border reminded me of a cooking app for some reason but I like it cause it makes it stand out.
38 Responses (page 1 of 2)
Icon of an app designed for Pinterest.I really can't decide which version looks more appropriate.My client believes that the icon doesn't relate to the site except the 'P'.So, both can be rejected as well.If you have a better idea/metaphor, do tell.
*Update
over 1 year ago
how about the left one with white notes?
over 1 year ago
diggin this alot
over 1 year ago
Nice Asher! I think I dig the second one the best. I think whats throwing it off is the "P". I think this feels more like a note taking app because the "P" is so much different than the Pinterest "P" - which I think would look really good in this icon. Just a thought :D
over 1 year ago
@Asher Top notch! Great work on the texture inside the wood and nice work on the pin too. ++
over 1 year ago
Definatelly the right one...
over 1 year ago
Nice! But I dont like the yellow sticker. Agreed with Mike - the second one the best
over 1 year ago
right.
yellow sticker doesn't work with a pin :)
over 1 year ago
I like the yellow version. And I also love the push pin :)
over 1 year ago
Why don't you use the Pinterest-branded 'P'?
over 1 year ago
right one is better
over 1 year ago
Nice!!
over 1 year ago
I'd like to see brighter background with the white pages, and maybe the Pinterest "P", looks great overall!
over 1 year ago
Both of them are really good man @Asher I would go for the second one, but I feel like there shoud be just one paper pinned (like in the forst one) or at least a darker shadow between the sheets. It should be white because the yellow one reminds me about the sticky notes which you never actually pin.
Besides that, I totally agree with @Mike Cummings a handwritten "P" is going to look so much better. Why don't you use the "P" from the actual Pinterest logo?
I really like that kind of posts on dribbble, that's what dribbble is all about, getting feedback from a truly creative and experienced community and not just showing off!
over 1 year ago
I am definitely going to use white note(s) on left frame.The reason why I avoided Pinterest logo was copyright infringement which, I believe, is not going to be a problem.
I'll work on ithe icon and will post the update soon.Thanks everyone for the constructive criticism :)
over 1 year ago
@Mike Cummings and @Ilie Ciorba not difficult to agree with them ;) handwritten "P" from logo will do the trick :) and like i write on twitter - right one are much better for me ;)
over 1 year ago
You are always welcome @Asher
over 1 year ago
Made the changes as suggested and came up with this.
over 1 year ago
@Asher Dude this looks so sexy :D i love it and i hope that your client love this :D
over 1 year ago
Think as mentioned before, left one with white notes and branded Pinterest "P" would do the work! Great job so far, love (pin) it ;)
over 1 year ago
The updated version looks pretty awesome!
over 1 year ago
@Lucas Veiga - Agreed :D
over 1 year ago
@Lucas Veiga Also agree, superb!!
over 1 year ago
The pin is spot on! My vote definitely goes for the updated version except I would change the shadow/stroke of the paper cause it looks a tad too sharp and orange. Grooves on the border reminded me of a cooking app for some reason but I like it cause it makes it stand out.
over 1 year ago
@Asher: Definitely post the update as a rebound, I want to Like it!
over 1 year ago