We are working hard on Sparrow iPhone and it should be available soon.
We are still not satisfied with the various icon iterations we made. It's hard for us after several months to take a step back and know what works best.
In the attached image, you'll find 9 different versions of the Sparrow icon.
We would like to know which one you'd like the most and gather some advice.
I would keep #1 (like the desktop one) but with a different hue of blue for the background...
Keep it simple! And keep the same icon for mobile / desktop IMO.
262 Responses (page 1 of 11)
Pro
Jean-Marc Denis
Dear Dribbblers,
We are working hard on Sparrow iPhone and it should be available soon.
We are still not satisfied with the various icon iterations we made. It's hard for us after several months to take a step back and know what works best.
In the attached image, you'll find 9 different versions of the Sparrow icon.
We would like to know which one you'd like the most and gather some advice.
Thanks a lot
about 1 year ago
Pro
Jack Bingham
I like the one featured in your shot — #8.
about 1 year ago
Pro
Andrew Ckor
For me works best, with exact order:
3 > 7 > 8
about 1 year ago
Number 5 is great. 6 also too.
about 1 year ago
Pro
Julien Martin
#1 with #7 background is a winner :)
about 1 year ago
Pro
Farzad Ban
#1 with a different background gradient.
about 1 year ago
7 > 8 > all.
about 1 year ago
Pro
Oliver Lukman
I was actually just thinking yesterday that I really love the one you guys are using for the beta.
about 1 year ago
#1 with #2's background
about 1 year ago
My favourite is #6 by far.
about 1 year ago
I would keep #1 (like the desktop one) but with a different hue of blue for the background...
Keep it simple! And keep the same icon for mobile / desktop IMO.
about 1 year ago
#1 for me.
about 1 year ago
6 by far. The glare makes it look a bit cheesy and Sparrow doesn't deserve that.
about 1 year ago
4# with the blue thing added to the plane
about 1 year ago
#5 or #6 look good to us.
about 1 year ago
#8
about 1 year ago
Number 8 iOS. Style ;)
about 1 year ago
#5 is awesome, but #1 combined with #4 background has much more "Sparrow style" in my opinion. Hard choice for me.
about 1 year ago
Pro
Adam Perfect
#1 with a different background colour (simple grey gradient perhaps?). The light blue doesn't fit well with the icon.
about 1 year ago
Love #5
about 1 year ago
Pro
Janik Baumgartner
2 or 4 - You have to make sure they go well with Apple's default icons, you don't want it to look out of place. Many of them would.
about 1 year ago
Pro
Filip Raatz
1 with the background of 2. Please dont change the white/blue combination :) i really like it!!
about 1 year ago
Pro
Christopher Downer
I really like 5, but if it was me, number 4. 2 is awesome but it's just too similar to Mail for me.
about 1 year ago
#2 & #5. They look great.
about 1 year ago
Pro
Loris Grillet
The 4 without the gloss or the 6 without the bump.
All of them are great but I like the simpler shapes and effects. :-)
about 1 year ago