I think it’s solid. Would it look better without the dark edge on the bottom of the inner rounded square? It looks like a drop shadow. Is that the intended effect? I’m looking at this as if it were like a payphone keypad button.
i really like the soft brushed metal on both the dark triangle interior and face of the button, as well as the shape of the triangle.
if i had any feedback i would say that the very outer edge, even as a round'rect, feels a bit sharp or maybe just 2-dimensional. is there room for a slight round bevel or something of the sort? just a thought! good luck, it looks like it's coming along nicely :)
4 Responses
Pro
Matt Downey
I don't usually do icons, so I'm looking for all the feedback I can get on this one. :)
4 months ago
Pro
John Williams
I think it’s solid. Would it look better without the dark edge on the bottom of the inner rounded square? It looks like a drop shadow. Is that the intended effect? I’m looking at this as if it were like a payphone keypad button.
4 months ago
Pro
Matt Downey
@John: Nice feedback, I'll definitely play around with that bottom edge and see if there's a way around that. Thanks!
4 months ago
i really like the soft brushed metal on both the dark triangle interior and face of the button, as well as the shape of the triangle.
if i had any feedback i would say that the very outer edge, even as a round'rect, feels a bit sharp or maybe just 2-dimensional. is there room for a slight round bevel or something of the sort? just a thought! good luck, it looks like it's coming along nicely :)
4 months ago