@Daniel: You just mean brighten them up a bit? If so, yeah that's where the final polishing will come in. Actually testing it out on the iPhone itself, seeing what looks best for the Retina.
Thank you in advance everyone. I do have the icon loaded up on the phone right now, the reflection isn't so bad shrunk down. But yeah, I could see ditching it! Woop woop, love you dribbblers.
I concur with Able, the one on the right is much more eye grabbing, but the reflection needs to go, or at least be toned down some more.
I also feel the solid thick white border seems a little harsh and detracts from the lightning bolt too much. I wonder whether the opacity could be reduced, or even be size it down to a 1-2px subtle stroke.
Liking the curtains though, looking forward to seeing this develop!
I think the one on the left could be really rad if it was more gold or bronze looking. I'm guessing this is for your Zeus related project, and Zeus had hella gold and shit.
Sounds like you already made a decision, but I prefer the left one! Once it's on a screen with 15 other icons plus the dock, the simpler one will definitely stand out more.
20 Responses
Pro
Patrick Algrim
Pick one! Help? Both will have some tweaking before they get finalized. But your vote counts! Oh yeah, and follow MyZeus on twitter, will ya, damnit!
almost 2 years ago
Pro
Daniel Waldron
They both feel a bit muddy to me, maybe less black and more of a saturated darker color to create the dark to light blends.
The curtain one is much more interesting and eye grabbing. ;)
almost 2 years ago
Pro
Patrick Algrim
@Daniel: You just mean brighten them up a bit? If so, yeah that's where the final polishing will come in. Actually testing it out on the iPhone itself, seeing what looks best for the Retina.
almost 2 years ago
it's curtains for you. (or the one i like the best)
almost 2 years ago
Definitely the curtain one!
The lightening bolt and icon border should be different colors, though. And ditch the bolt's reflection.
–2¢
almost 2 years ago
Ditto what Able said.
almost 2 years ago
Pro
Paulo Zoom
The right one is better, but I agree with Able. The reflection is distracting.
almost 2 years ago
Pro
Patrick Algrim
Thank you in advance everyone. I do have the icon loaded up on the phone right now, the reflection isn't so bad shrunk down. But yeah, I could see ditching it! Woop woop, love you dribbblers.
almost 2 years ago
Pro
James Gill
I concur with Able, the one on the right is much more eye grabbing, but the reflection needs to go, or at least be toned down some more.
I also feel the solid thick white border seems a little harsh and detracts from the lightning bolt too much. I wonder whether the opacity could be reduced, or even be size it down to a 1-2px subtle stroke.
Liking the curtains though, looking forward to seeing this develop!
almost 2 years ago
I think the one on the left could be really rad if it was more gold or bronze looking. I'm guessing this is for your Zeus related project, and Zeus had hella gold and shit.
almost 2 years ago
Sounds like you already made a decision, but I prefer the left one! Once it's on a screen with 15 other icons plus the dock, the simpler one will definitely stand out more.
almost 2 years ago
Taking back what I said after seeing these show up much smaller in my timeline. The simpler one wins.
http://cl.ly/694defc6cda44d40c033 [screenshot]
@Bobby: Awesome.
almost 2 years ago
sans curtain... but they are both sick... call a docta!
almost 2 years ago
Pro
Sean O'Grady
left one is nicer, much cleaner
almost 2 years ago
Pro
Tim Boelaars
I like the left one. But the right one is cool as well!
almost 2 years ago
Pro
Patrick Algrim
Thank you all once more. Keep it coming! The left one definitely shrinks well. But it might need a bit more glow to stand out from the crowd.
almost 2 years ago
Pro
Miro Keller
Go, right, go!
almost 2 years ago
Pro
Kyle Steed
You definitely need to go minimal. The curtain idea is cool but it's just too cluttered. And kill the reflection. ;)
almost 2 years ago
Pro
Krystyn Heide
I like the one on the right. There's too many minimal ones out there IMHO, and I don't doubt there's already a few with lightning bolts. ;)
I think maybe a hardwood or richer color on the floor would make it pop.
almost 2 years ago
Right.
almost 2 years ago