This looks very nice, but it is too sparse and spacious. I can only speak from my experience (being a daily HN reader for over two years), but the design feature of HN web interface is its information density - 20-30 headlines per page. It helps assessing the state and the dynamics of the stories at a glance and it is essential to the HN browsing experience. Having only 3-4 stories in a view just ain't gonna work.
@Alex I understand your point, and I actually thought about that as I was putting it all together. The idea behind this view however is that you could still scroll through as many stories as you'd like (or that are listed on the pages of the HN screen scrape).
I think the density of stories is more of a preference thing than anything. Unlike you, I find the HN site very difficult to read, as there is no differentiation between links, story titles, comments, authors, etc. It's very difficult for me to scan anything.
Perhaps it's something we could customize in the Settings -- having a dense and sparse view...
Well, it wasn't easy, but I got used to Paul's interface. It is really a gem if you let it grow on you :)
In any case, I really hope you tackle some usability issues with your app rather than just the presentation. For example, being able to hide unwanted stories from the front page (and therefore get more stories pulled up from the second page) would be an awesome thing to have.
Why not take a page from the latest GMail redesign and offer multiple information density settings?
Also, maybe that's outside the scope of the app, but it would be awesome to have a feature that automatically download the first 10 stories for offline reading.
12 Responses
Pro
Ryan Scherf
Just playing around with more ideas for http://www.hnreaderapp.com/. Had a developer bail, but a new one stepped up...
6 months ago
Pro
Daniel Waldron
How have I not heard of this already? This looks hot Ryan!
6 months ago
Pro
Bob Galmarini
looks really nice!
6 months ago
Pro
Alexandre Deschamps
Lookin' good!
6 months ago
Pro
Brian Potstra
This is looking fantastic. The colour scheme is spot on.
6 months ago
Pro
Curtis McClain
I love the mastery in balance of proportions.
6 months ago
Pro
Callum Chapman
Can picture how this will work. Looking forward to playing with it!
6 months ago
Pro
Alex Pankratov
This looks very nice, but it is too sparse and spacious. I can only speak from my experience (being a daily HN reader for over two years), but the design feature of HN web interface is its information density - 20-30 headlines per page. It helps assessing the state and the dynamics of the stories at a glance and it is essential to the HN browsing experience. Having only 3-4 stories in a view just ain't gonna work.
6 months ago
Pro
Ryan Scherf
@Alex I understand your point, and I actually thought about that as I was putting it all together. The idea behind this view however is that you could still scroll through as many stories as you'd like (or that are listed on the pages of the HN screen scrape).
I think the density of stories is more of a preference thing than anything. Unlike you, I find the HN site very difficult to read, as there is no differentiation between links, story titles, comments, authors, etc. It's very difficult for me to scan anything.
Perhaps it's something we could customize in the Settings -- having a dense and sparse view...
6 months ago
Pro
Alex Pankratov
Well, it wasn't easy, but I got used to Paul's interface. It is really a gem if you let it grow on you :)
In any case, I really hope you tackle some usability issues with your app rather than just the presentation. For example, being able to hide unwanted stories from the front page (and therefore get more stories pulled up from the second page) would be an awesome thing to have.
6 months ago
Pro
Sacha Greif
Why not take a page from the latest GMail redesign and offer multiple information density settings?
Also, maybe that's outside the scope of the app, but it would be awesome to have a feature that automatically download the first 10 stories for offline reading.
6 months ago
Pro
Ryan Scherf
@Sacha those would certainly be cool features, but probably won't be ready on a first iteration. Thanks for the feedback & suggestions though!
6 months ago