I think that C is repetitive cause its going to say You Rather under the app anyway, A seems very solid, with the circle and shadow around the question mark, whereas B seems more flat and too spread out in my opinion.
What about a combo of A and C? Size up the two bars to stretch across the icon (but keep the points on the ends) and the place the question mark in the middle over top of them. I think it would keep what I like about C (two opposing forces).
9 Responses
Pro
Sam Dunn
We're currently having a debate regarding what the app icon for You Rather should be - which one is your choice? I'd love feedback.
over 1 year ago
C
over 1 year ago
A!
I think that C is repetitive cause its going to say You Rather under the app anyway, A seems very solid, with the circle and shadow around the question mark, whereas B seems more flat and too spread out in my opinion.
Hope you guys are well!
over 1 year ago
Pro
Matthew Skiles
C
over 1 year ago
Pro
Andy Thompson
What about a combo of A and C? Size up the two bars to stretch across the icon (but keep the points on the ends) and the place the question mark in the middle over top of them. I think it would keep what I like about C (two opposing forces).
over 1 year ago
i agree with Andy on this, but don't have anything written inside the two bars, let the title under the app speak for itself. just my 2 cents.
over 1 year ago
Definitely B.
over 1 year ago
Pro
Sam Dunn
Thanks for the feedback everyone - we definitely are gonna try out something like what Andy suggested.
over 1 year ago
Rebound
You Rather App Icon
by Sam Dunn
After a good amount of debate we settled on this icon for the You Rather iOS and Android apps.
See this in the wild on the mobile app splash page
over 1 year ago