Looking for some criticism but more specifically a choice between a GREY or BLUE sky.
The top icon is the Elements app icon. The two icons below are the choices for a different concept based on Elements and cloud support.
7 months ago
GREY sky.
Hmmm.. Im a fan of the "lined paper" look in the current one. But if I had to choose I'd say grey.
Yup, grey sky for sure :)
Sky? Blue more usual. And if you add to a cloud lines as in the previous version of the icon?
Love the version without the cloud! If I had to pick a cloud I'd say grey. Either way it's a win/win situation.
Thx for the input so far everyone. Just to sooth any concerns, this is not an icon replacement. I just put the original one up top for context.
@Paul, I do think the clouds need some texture.
Grey
Grey, the blue line stands out more
@Eddie Yeah I thought/hoped as much, in which case I love it even more.
SecondGear also did a few surveys and grey is the winner. Thanks once again for the input everyone.
Blue sky. No question. No one likes rain.
Hot stuff! I'm a fan of the blue sky, the grey make it look like its inactive or disabled.
Blue sky!
Please, Eddie, leave the old one untouched. Nowadays everything works with the cloud. There's no need to mention it on every icon.
@Alex No worries, the current icon is staying the same :-) The cloud version is for a different purpose.
Have to tell you, the original is still my favorite.
My name is Eddy, and I wanted to say that it is good to see a fellow Edward doing amazing work like you do. Keep it up. :)
5 months ago
keyboard shortcuts: ← previous shot → next shot L or F like
19 Responses
Looking for some criticism but more specifically a choice between a GREY or BLUE sky.
The top icon is the Elements app icon. The two icons below are the choices for a different concept based on Elements and cloud support.
7 months ago
Pro
Tim Van Damme
GREY sky.
7 months ago
Hmmm.. Im a fan of the "lined paper" look in the current one. But if I had to choose I'd say grey.
7 months ago
Yup, grey sky for sure :)
7 months ago
Pro
Paul Grozyan
Sky? Blue more usual. And if you add to a cloud lines as in the previous version of the icon?
7 months ago
Pro
Liam McKay
Love the version without the cloud! If I had to pick a cloud I'd say grey. Either way it's a win/win situation.
7 months ago
Thx for the input so far everyone. Just to sooth any concerns, this is not an icon replacement. I just put the original one up top for context.
7 months ago
@Paul, I do think the clouds need some texture.
7 months ago
Grey
7 months ago
Pro
Matt Vague
Grey, the blue line stands out more
7 months ago
Pro
Liam McKay
@Eddie Yeah I thought/hoped as much, in which case I love it even more.
7 months ago
SecondGear also did a few surveys and grey is the winner. Thanks once again for the input everyone.
7 months ago
Blue sky. No question. No one likes rain.
7 months ago
Pro
Timothy Achumba
Hot stuff! I'm a fan of the blue sky, the grey make it look like its inactive or disabled.
7 months ago
Pro
Oneeyedman
Blue sky!
7 months ago
Pro
Alex Solonsky
Please, Eddie, leave the old one untouched. Nowadays everything works with the cloud. There's no need to mention it on every icon.
7 months ago
@Alex No worries, the current icon is staying the same :-) The cloud version is for a different purpose.
7 months ago
Pro
Jeff Rock
Have to tell you, the original is still my favorite.
7 months ago
Pro
Eddy G
My name is Eddy, and I wanted to say that it is good to see a fellow Edward doing amazing work like you do. Keep it up. :)
5 months ago