Looks great. This looks like it could possibly be a design for retina, in which case complaining about the noise/grain doesn't make much sense without the context of seeing it on the device; Which most likely looks great.
Only thing I'd pick on is the highlights around each inactive tab. Seems strange that at the corners the highlight is doubled (brighter). Also, you've probably already checked this, but at 1px it might be too subdued on retina.
Which is another observation, that there's a lot of 1px lines going on here. That can be a dangerous approach when designing @2x designs … but if you've already checked them and they look great on the device … as long as you're okay with the maintainability of it, no rule not to do it.
Hey Josh, Good catch on the corners! I'll have to tweak those some more if I go with this style.
The 1px strokes are all intentional and surprisingly look quite crisp on the device. Love the detailed feedback man!
18 Responses
Pro
Collin Henderson
Maybe it's because it's zoomed in to full size but I'd maybe tone the grain down a little.
Then again i don't know the scope of the rest of the UI so maybe it fits.
ANYWAY HI DANIEL
10 months ago
I like the texture on this. It makes me want to touch my screen, haha.
10 months ago
Pro
Daniel Waldron
Yeah it definitely looks crazy full size, but is barely noticeable on the device. :)
10 months ago
Pro
Sully Taylor
It's too noisy, I think I'm going to go deff.
10 months ago
Pro
Daniel Waldron
Remember that this is @2x. ;)
10 months ago
It looks toggled :)
Maybe a little inset shadowing on the bottom edge. Unless the goal is for the top to look tilted in. What do I know?
10 months ago
Pro
Daniel Waldron
It's concave and convex. Kinda the desired look.
10 months ago
Pro
Yummygum
yes!
10 months ago
@Daniel Waldron, brilliant work once again.
10 months ago
looks awesome on the device. Really nice!
10 months ago
how fancy of you
10 months ago
Pro
Josh Bryant
Looks great. This looks like it could possibly be a design for retina, in which case complaining about the noise/grain doesn't make much sense without the context of seeing it on the device; Which most likely looks great.
Only thing I'd pick on is the highlights around each inactive tab. Seems strange that at the corners the highlight is doubled (brighter). Also, you've probably already checked this, but at 1px it might be too subdued on retina.
Which is another observation, that there's a lot of 1px lines going on here. That can be a dangerous approach when designing @2x designs … but if you've already checked them and they look great on the device … as long as you're okay with the maintainability of it, no rule not to do it.
Overall, love it!
10 months ago
Pro
Daniel Waldron
Hey Josh, Good catch on the corners! I'll have to tweak those some more if I go with this style.
The 1px strokes are all intentional and surprisingly look quite crisp on the device. Love the detailed feedback man!
10 months ago
too noisy for my taste
10 months ago
Pro
Daniel Waldron
Juan no one is making you eat it.
10 months ago
Why all the noise?
10 months ago
Pro
Daniel Waldron
MOAR NOISE!
10 months ago
Pro
Juan Arreguin
Actually there might be too little of noise!
Bring the Noise Gods and add mooooar!!!
10 months ago