Crazy perspectives! :D
It's almost as if it curves when it goes to the left, others that that there is a stunning amount of detail!
EDIT: I just saw it how it's meant to look! Idea is awesome
I hate writing critique, but I'm going to write some anyway because I feel this icon needs it.
First off, I think the icon should be rotated by 90 degrees due to the unnatural highlights and shadows. They don't make sense coming from both left and right sides. Simplifying the icon would make it look a million times better. Secondly, the 3D should be changed or completely removed to make space for the screen details you've made. It would look a heap better than what you're doing right now.
Looking at your scaled icons, they have way too much detail for such a small size. They are blurry and it looks like you're trying too hard to fit everything in. Use darker strokes and delete unnecessary details that detain from the main focus of this app. To compensate for the excess amount of detail, I think it would look better if you got rid of the knob at the lower right. It's unnecessary and it doesn't represent what this app does (I could be wrong, but still).
Anyway, I hope you take these points in mind and adjust accordingly. Cheers man :)
6 Responses
Pro
Jack Thomas
Crazy perspectives! :D
It's almost as if it curves when it goes to the left, others that that there is a stunning amount of detail!
EDIT: I just saw it how it's meant to look! Idea is awesome
almost 2 years ago
Pro
Andrew Ckor
Great details man! :) POPULAR!!!
almost 2 years ago
Pro
Mantas Sutkus
Too much details.
almost 2 years ago
crazy! however i agree with Mantas, it's too much details IMO
almost 2 years ago
I hate writing critique, but I'm going to write some anyway because I feel this icon needs it.
First off, I think the icon should be rotated by 90 degrees due to the unnatural highlights and shadows. They don't make sense coming from both left and right sides. Simplifying the icon would make it look a million times better. Secondly, the 3D should be changed or completely removed to make space for the screen details you've made. It would look a heap better than what you're doing right now.
Looking at your scaled icons, they have way too much detail for such a small size. They are blurry and it looks like you're trying too hard to fit everything in. Use darker strokes and delete unnecessary details that detain from the main focus of this app. To compensate for the excess amount of detail, I think it would look better if you got rid of the knob at the lower right. It's unnecessary and it doesn't represent what this app does (I could be wrong, but still).
Anyway, I hope you take these points in mind and adjust accordingly. Cheers man :)
almost 2 years ago
Pro
Aditya Nugraha Putra
Wohoow, easy @Nik... you are giving me more homework, weekend is just start. :(
Thank a ton anyway, I really appreciated it. Thanks all :)
almost 2 years ago