maybe a combination of both? i like the logo and tab bar from the right but the subtle elements from the left. (ie: reply box, line dividers) I do like the simplicity of the photo stream from the left, but I can see an issue with a long stream title breaking that simplicity, for that i like the right much better.
Either way, they both look great but I agree with the majority of the posts so far. The texture in the blue bar looks a little trendy, where the one on the right seems sets a more confident tone. It also puts more emphasis on the actual content.
right definitely. The blue takes away from the photos (and is a little dated) but the right palette sets a neutral canvas for the rich photos to sit on top of.
44 Responses (page 1 of 2)
Pro
Robin Raszka
Full-size: Left or Right? That's the question.
What do you think?
about 2 years ago
Definitely prefer the right, more focus on the content. I prefer the tab bar from the left though :) Excellent work!
about 2 years ago
Yup, I agree with Robbie. The version on the right with the active tab style from the version on the left.
about 2 years ago
Pro
Josh Pigford
I prefer the right, but I think the "selected" state of the nav item seems too subtle.
about 2 years ago
Pro
Sean Farrell
I prefer the left
about 2 years ago
I’m also with Robbie.
about 2 years ago
Pro
Dick
I love the integrated title & tab bars, but the left has a clearer distinction between the title, nav and content.
about 2 years ago
Pro
Dick
In response to Robbie, I think the left has an easier understanding of the content. Both examples have clear focus on the content, though.
Sorry Robbie...just playing devils advocate :)
about 2 years ago
right.
about 2 years ago
Pro
matt ⚒
maybe a combination of both? i like the logo and tab bar from the right but the subtle elements from the left. (ie: reply box, line dividers) I do like the simplicity of the photo stream from the left, but I can see an issue with a long stream title breaking that simplicity, for that i like the right much better.
about 2 years ago
Pro
Jeff Broderick
I like the right more. Well done!
about 2 years ago
I agree completely with Taylor. Bring the photo reply button over from the left as well.
about 2 years ago
The right one, except with more distinct selected states from the left one and with the content division lines/alternate row colors.
about 2 years ago
Right one.
about 2 years ago
Pro
Sergio Alvarez
Right one :)
about 2 years ago
right :)
about 2 years ago
Pro
Benjamin Hahn
I prefer the right one!
about 2 years ago
>>>>>>>>>>>>
i'd say bump up the darkness of the dark links and text on the right one a couple of shades and it will be awesome
about 2 years ago
Pro
Joey Lomanto
Either way, they both look great but I agree with the majority of the posts so far. The texture in the blue bar looks a little trendy, where the one on the right seems sets a more confident tone. It also puts more emphasis on the actual content.
about 2 years ago
Pro
Alex Patrascu
I like the Right one for the 90% of it, except the bottom bar which is better on the left imo.
about 2 years ago
Pro
Ahmed Chergaoui
Right one
about 2 years ago
Pro
Tomas Bartko
Right, looks more detailed to me.
about 2 years ago
Pro
Maxi Kräßig
I prefer the right. Colors are more powerful, less distracting. Very clean. Nice blur at the Tab bar by the way.
about 2 years ago
Pro
David Hellmann
right!
about 2 years ago
right definitely. The blue takes away from the photos (and is a little dated) but the right palette sets a neutral canvas for the rich photos to sit on top of.
about 2 years ago