Cheers Jase. The heart vs. star debate is one of the reasons I'm posting these. I wouldn't normally go against such an established convention, but a heart representing something you love makes sense to me...
I think it depends on subject mater – something like a tweet works better as a star; a heart would be over the top. Something like a film, that you are possibly quite passionate about, a heart is just right.
@Chris: I hadn't come across Shelfworthy until now. To be honest, I think we'll be lucky just to get films right (well, the way we want it), never mind games and books. You're brave! Best of luck :)
9 Responses
Pro
Robbie Manson
Some UI detail (sans-logo) from a web app currently in development. Keen to get thoughts from some fresh eyes!
about 2 years ago
I like it fella, I also like that you have used a heart for favourites .. I'm doing the same on my current project and it divides opinion.
I like purple anyway, so yeah.
about 2 years ago
Pro
Robbie Manson
Cheers Jase. The heart vs. star debate is one of the reasons I'm posting these. I wouldn't normally go against such an established convention, but a heart representing something you love makes sense to me...
about 2 years ago
Pro
Pete Lacey
I've been in 'Star Camp' up until the last few months really. I'm now a confirmed member of 'Heart Camp'.
Great little bit of UI.
about 2 years ago
I think it depends on subject mater – something like a tweet works better as a star; a heart would be over the top. Something like a film, that you are possibly quite passionate about, a heart is just right.
about 2 years ago
Pro
Michael Whalen
I really dig that 15px gap between the rows in the table and the left sidebar. Makes it look real clean.
about 2 years ago
Pro
Sam Brown
Looking good Robbie, definitely think the Heart is appropriate here. Interface is nice, interested to see it in action.
about 2 years ago
looks like my little shelfworthy.com might be getting more competition soon ;)
we're used to it on the book front, but from this it seems we'll have some on the movie front as well :)
Great Job on the highlight in the sidebar by the way, I love it!
about 2 years ago
Pro
Robbie Manson
@Chris: I hadn't come across Shelfworthy until now. To be honest, I think we'll be lucky just to get films right (well, the way we want it), never mind games and books. You're brave! Best of luck :)
about 2 years ago