Barleys Rate Beer Form Continued

16 Responses

1. Thommy Browne

   MMMmmmm, rate beer I will

   about 2 years ago

2. Pro Christopher Meeks

   I like the addition of the lines. It still is really clever, but feels more official and understandable.

   about 2 years ago

3. Pro Kyle Meyer

   Glow on the active one is a little too subtle... maybe tighten it back up towards the glass and raise the opacity a tad? It's nice that things are brown but the lack of contrast (on buttons for example) is a bit annoying.

   about 2 years ago

4. Marko Prljic

   You seriously love beer, right? Great stuff! Like.

   about 2 years ago

5. Pro Erica Burnett

   Great details in the design. Mmmm beer.

   about 2 years ago

6. Pro Jeffrey Zeldman

   I don't like beer but I like this.

   about 2 years ago

7. Pro Pete Orme

   Beery beery beer, slipping own my throat. Lovely!

   about 2 years ago

8. Sahil Lavingia

   Working with Blue Flavor?!

   about 2 years ago

9. Pro Trent Walton

   +1 for what Chris said... on and ++1 for what Erica said.

   about 2 years ago

10. Pro Benji Smith

    I want to drink this design.

    about 2 years ago

11. Pro Rob Soulé

    Hey bro! I'm digging this and would love to see it in the wild. A couple quick thoughts:
    *I really liked the dimension that the glasses had here and it seems like adding that back in to the rating would be a nice tough. Right now it seems a bit off since the glass is slightly rounded but the rating, or fill, is straight.
    *Take this one with a grain of salt but it feels very monochromatic. Everything kinda blends together a bit. That's not necessarily a bad thing but it might be nice to add a splash of color in places to help the eye path.

    about 2 years ago

12. Pro Jeremy Jantz

    I'm digging the lines. It makes it obvious the glass is segmented, more clearly defines the potential options for the user, and keeps the fill line from being vague.

    For me the addition of the lines also solves the "is full or empty better" argument. I was struggling with that visual metaphor in the earlier iterations, but not feeling that struggle anymore. I think the full-is-better is more understandable for most users, although maybe not as clever.

    Really good work, Matthew.

    about 2 years ago

13. Pro Vin Thomas

    Really like this. The one suggestion is that the different shades of beer "fullness" is a little confusing. I would have a single shade for the beer.

    about 2 years ago

14. Pro Matthew Smith

    different shades show hover, active, normal ;)

    about 2 years ago

15. Pro Ali Ali

    I am in love!

    about 2 years ago

16. Pro Yummygum

    Cool, this seems really fun for a user/visitor to fill out/participate!

    over 1 year ago