I like the idea. I see it pretty quickly. Are the leaves supposed to be a collar for the dog perspective?
I do feel that the shapes/outlines benefit the bird over the dog. But I seem to see the dog first (probably because of the long nose) and as a dog he has a funny looking ear and face.
I've shown this to others prior to posting, and so far, some see the bird first, others the dog. It really doesn't matter. I was just hoping to have people take a second look at it. Felt that this would create more of a memorable mark.
If you aren't dead set on the stick/leaves, I was thinking you could try a simple bordering line to contain the dog a bit more... Something like > THIS
I didn't see the bird first... I saw a dog with a branch in his mouth actually... I think maybe making the beak a bit smaller and improving the flow from head to beak would bring out the bird more, without affecting the dog much. The only reason the leaves don't work for me is the positioning... too much going on in that one spot for me.
@Sergey. Thanks - that's what I had intended.
@Matt. I've tried playing with beak size. It's hard when you're playing with two shapes when one small change can really effect the other animal/bird in a big way. Thanks for the comment.
Great idea! Really cute shapes and nice color palette.
I saw the bird first, I think due to the leaves. I think without them the dog would read first. I don't think you need the leaves, but the green is nice in terms of color. When I focus on the dog shape the leaves don't read as dog tags, rather I'm wondering why he has leaves on his neck.
Interesting michael. At first, I thought of doing a circle with the animals/bird inside but didn't work as well. Also, logomotive mike did create a circle with three animals inside already.
54 Responses (page 1 of 3)
Wip design. Would love to know if you see the bird/animal combo in the mark easily.
over 1 year ago
Pro
Breno Bitencourt
Looks great, James.
over 1 year ago
Thanks breno. Is the concept seen quickly enough?
over 1 year ago
Pro
â–²Claudiu Ungureanu
beautiful work, James - it might need some refinments on the eye and nose. i don't like the leaves. perhaps get rid of those.
over 1 year ago
I feel that the leaves help bring out the bird more. Unless it's obvious enough without them. If so, then I guess it's unnecessary.
over 1 year ago
Pro
Nitish (Maskon)
nice direction james, will keep an eye on this guy. al da best
over 1 year ago
I like the idea. I see it pretty quickly. Are the leaves supposed to be a collar for the dog perspective?
I do feel that the shapes/outlines benefit the bird over the dog. But I seem to see the dog first (probably because of the long nose) and as a dog he has a funny looking ear and face.
Hope my two cents is helpful.
over 1 year ago
Pro
Luke Ritchie
good work! i see the dog more than i see the bird.also dont think leaves are working..
over 1 year ago
I think by removing the leaves it will make the colors blend more.
@Terry. Yes, they were to double as a collar.
I've shown this to others prior to posting, and so far, some see the bird first, others the dog. It really doesn't matter. I was just hoping to have people take a second look at it. Felt that this would create more of a memorable mark.
over 1 year ago
Pro
Richard Young
Absolutely superb.
over 1 year ago
I love the leaves/dog tags. I think that really adds an extra element of surprise to the design. Nice work!
over 1 year ago
Pro
Jord Riekwel
Wow. 0.0
over 1 year ago
Pro
Michael Spitz
Looking good buddy :)
If you aren't dead set on the stick/leaves, I was thinking you could try a simple bordering line to contain the dog a bit more... Something like > THIS
over 1 year ago
I've tried doing that too. It's a good idea to contain the dog more, but it also creates that space that doesn't fit with the bird.
I guess it's an option. Thanks Michael.
over 1 year ago
Pro
Sergey Shapiro
Saw the dog at first and then the carrot. Nice!
over 1 year ago
Pro
Matt Kump
I didn't see the bird first... I saw a dog with a branch in his mouth actually... I think maybe making the beak a bit smaller and improving the flow from head to beak would bring out the bird more, without affecting the dog much. The only reason the leaves don't work for me is the positioning... too much going on in that one spot for me.
over 1 year ago
@Sergey. Thanks - that's what I had intended.
@Matt. I've tried playing with beak size. It's hard when you're playing with two shapes when one small change can really effect the other animal/bird in a big way. Thanks for the comment.
over 1 year ago
Shot you an email James.
over 1 year ago
I saw the bird first. Not sure why. Good concept james.
over 1 year ago
Great idea! Really cute shapes and nice color palette.
I saw the bird first, I think due to the leaves. I think without them the dog would read first. I don't think you need the leaves, but the green is nice in terms of color. When I focus on the dog shape the leaves don't read as dog tags, rather I'm wondering why he has leaves on his neck.
Interested to see where you take this!
over 1 year ago
Pro
Michael Spitz
Yeah, I hear ya. On the other hand that random negative space does kind of look like a CAT... Ha! ;)
over 1 year ago
Interesting michael. At first, I thought of doing a circle with the animals/bird inside but didn't work as well. Also, logomotive mike did create a circle with three animals inside already.
over 1 year ago
Pro
Michael Spitz
Yeah I know that one Mike did... I think he's got a fish in there as well?
In any case, again, definitely like the approach :)
over 1 year ago
yes, land, air, and sea theme.
over 1 year ago
Pro
Made By Thomas
Didn't see the bird straight away, but loving the concept. Not a fan of the leaves either.
over 1 year ago